2010 Wall Street Trillion-Dollar Flash Crash – Genius Trader Sarao Made Scapegoat?

Pin It

Apr 26 2015
Linked In

Navinder Singh Sarao was a 36-year-old British futures trader, just like any other traders trying to make money. But the Brunel University graduate is now spending his weekend in British jail after failing to up his £5 million (US$7.6 million, RM27.1 million) bail bond. He was arrested this week at the modest suburban semi in Hounslow, London, where he lives with his parents.

Navinder Singh Sarao  - Charged at Westminster Court

His crime? Accused of helping (or causing) to spark the notorious American “flash crash” of May, 2010, during which the Dow Jones plunged more than a thousand points for no apparent reason. It wiped out £500 million (US$760 million, RM2.7 billion) in a 20-minutes-panic selling on May 6, 2010. By the time the market closed, Mr Sarao had made a cool US$879,018 (£578,796, RM3.14 million) for the day.

Navinder Singh Sarao  - Charged at Westminster Court - Graphic

Strangely, it took 5-years for the US Department of Justice and Commodity Futures Trading Commission to charge Mr Sarao this week, for allegedly contributing to the panic that day and embarking on a pattern of behaviour that is said to have netted him nearly US$40 million (£26 million, RM143 million) in four years. Not bad for a trader who described himself as “an old school point and click trader”, using his computer mouse to place each trade.

US Commodity Futures Trading Commission

He is also fighting efforts by US authorities to extradite him to Illinois to be tried for one count of wire fraud, ten counts of commodities fraud, ten counts of commodities manipulation and one count of spoofing. That’s right, spoofing, is the name of the game for Mr Sarao. Spoofing is the tactic of placing large orders and quickly cancelling them, which sometimes is used to move prices in the market and generate short-term trading profits.


However, unlike previous rogue traders who caused billions of dollars in losses, such as Nick Leeson who ultimately caused the collapsed of Barings Bank, Mr Sarao didn’t have the balance sheet of a big financial institution behind him. Mr Sarao was a lone day trader who often conducted business out of his parents’ modest suburban home, in his pyjamas.

Navinder Singh Sarao Parents Home - Inset Photo

But here’s the problem – nobody on Wall Street believes Navinder Singh Sarao single-handedly contributed to the “flash crash”, let alone caused close to a trillion dollar losses in a matter of minutes. That’s because almost all (huge) fund managers use “spoofing” tactic every single day. Strangely, he’s the only person accused in connection with the flash crash, prompting speculation that  Mr Sarao has been made a scapegoat.


Mr Sarao admitted he was a day trader who changes his mind very, very quickly but that was his unique trading style. His former colleagues said he would never come out drinking, never socialise and drove around in a beat-up Vauxhall Corsa. Despite his alleged wealth, he would travel to work late so he could buy off-peak tickets, only have lunch if he could find discounted sandwiches and shunned drinking in pubs for pints of milk at his desk.

Navinder Singh Sarao Parents Home

Amazingly, not only he was good in making money but not spending it, he was also so secretive about his wealth that his mother worked two jobs to make ends meet unaware that her son was actually sitting on a US$40 million (£26 million, RM143 million) fortune. He worked at Futex prior to the 2010 crash, where he got his first trading job. When he left Futex in 2008, he took £2.5 million (US$3.8 million, RM13.6 million) with him.


He formed his own company – Nav Sarao Futures Limited – which had a turnover of £19.6 million from May 2011 to October 2013, but made a loss of £31.7 million. Sarao set up a second company, International Guarantee Corporation, in Anguilla, another Caribbean tax haven. Prosecutors said this company, together with Nav Sarao Milking Markets Limited, an offshore on the Caribbean Island of Nevis, was setup as part of a tax avoidance strategy.

Navinder Singh Sarao  - with School Mates

As much as the US authorities want to put the blame solely on Mr Sarao, the fact remains that an official report was established that on the day of “flash crash”, a US$4.1 billion (£2.7 billion, RM14.6 billion) transaction of stock index futures alone was done by a single institutional investor, Waddell & Reed, which began at 2:32pm EST. So, why only blames Navinder Singh Sarao, whose trades were much smaller than that?


Other Articles That May Interest You …

Pin It

FinanceTwitter SignOff
If you enjoyed this post, what shall you do next? Consider:

Like FinanceTwitter Tweet FinanceTwitter Subscribe Newsletter   Leave Comment Share With Others


Add your comment now.

Leave a Reply


(required)(will not be published)