Challenging The Constitution – Trump Plans To Sign An Executive Order To Stop Birthright Citizenship

Pin It

Oct 31 2018
Linked In

As the midterm elections approaching fast, President Donald Trump appear to have one last tool to excite his supporters – the white nationalist and conservative movement. And he has proudly declared that he is a nationalist days ago, just in case you’re wondering. But what he plans to do next will make his supporters go wild. He’s going to terminate birthright citizenship.


“We’re the only country in the world where a person comes in and has a baby, and the baby is essentially a citizen of the United States for 85 years with all of those benefits. It’s ridiculous. It’s ridiculous. And it has to end,” – Donald Trump said during an interview with Axios. However, according to NumbersUSA, there are 33 nations that grant citizenship to anyone born within their borders.


But how does Trump plan to do that? The 14th Amendment to the Constitution says – “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” Apparently the U.S. president has a magic wand – the “Executive Order”.

Trump To Eliminate Birthright Citizenship - 14th Amendment - Baby

Yes, Trump said Monday he will sign an executive order that would remove the right to citizenship for babies of noncitizens and undocumented immigrants born on U.S. soil. “It was always told to me that you needed a constitutional amendment. Guess what? You don’t. It’s in the process. It’ll happen … with an executive order.” Trump said in the interview


Trump’s plan to bulldoze the Constitution with his executive order would definitely trigger another constitutional standoff. Critics have argued, even laughed at Trump, that it’s not within the president’s power to change birthright citizenship. But the president doesn’t care as he continues to push a hard anti-immigration line ahead of next week’s midterm elections.


President Trump claims that he has discussed the move with his legal counsel and believes it can be accomplished with executive action, a view at odds with the opinions of many legal scholars. Legal scholars have widely interpreted the 14th Amendment to mean that anyone born on American soil automatically becomes a natural-born citizen.

Donald Trump - Thumbs Up and Kiss

However, some other scholars have argued that the case for birthright citizenship is based on a misreading of the 14th Amendment, which was drafted in relation to former slaves following the US Civil War. Interestingly, the 14th Amendment, passed in 1868 to grant citizenship to former slaves, is one of the most heavily litigated provisions of the Constitution.


Since at least 1898, the Supreme Court has held that it grants citizenship to children of noncitizens. Hence, it’s hard to imagine how Trump’s executive order could suddenly emerge victorious. In a 19th-century case – United States v. Wong Kim Ark – the court ruled that a child of Chinese parents who was born in San Francisco was a U.S. citizen by virtue of his California birth.


James C. Ho, a conservative lawyer whom Trump appointed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit last year, wrote in a 2006 paper titled “Birthright Citizenship and the Original Understanding of the 14th Amendment” that any legislation that removed birthright citizenship would likely be voided by the nation’s courts.

Trump To Eliminate Birthright Citizenship - Cartoon

He wrote – “All three branches of our government – Congress, the courts, and the Executive Branch – agree that the Citizenship Clause applies to the children of aliens and citizens alike.” But that doesn’t mean Trump cannot try to poke the Constitution. After all, his intention has been political, not legal, in his latest stunt to go against foreign immigrants.


The truth is he would have a better success with his executive order to limit travel to the U.S. from a number of Muslim-majority countries, an idea hatched in his first year in office. But if Trump could not even get that done without tons of backlashes from the courts, it’s a wishful thinking that his next executive order to remove birthright citizenship would have a better chance of success.


Adding salt to the injury, the birthright citizenship is protected and was further enshrined in an act of Congress, the 1866 Civil Rights Act. The Act was the first United States federal law to define citizenship and affirm that all citizens are equally protected by the law. Although it was vetoed by President Andrew Johnson, the legislation was passed by Congress with overwhelming two-thirds majority.


Other Articles That May Interest You …

Pin It

FinanceTwitter SignOff
If you enjoyed this post, what shall you do next? Consider:

Like FinanceTwitter Tweet FinanceTwitter Subscribe Newsletter   Leave Comment Share With Others


Hello Finance Twitter,

You appear to be quite an informed and savvy ‘journalist’ but it’s interesting to note you’re quite misinformed about Trump.

Switch off your CNN and MSNBC news channel and et all and you’ll probably have a clearer view.

Trump, warts and all, is the best leader in the modern world to have surfaced. He’s not bought and is aware of most things wrong that are going on. To me he’s the best US President so far and he has the people’s interest at heart.

Watch, the day he and Putin and Xi can get together and put all wars and hostilities behind there will be peace on Earth.

Right now, Trump is dismantling the globalists’ goal to put in place a NWO – and that’s a good thing.

Read ‘Confessions of An Economic Hitman’ by John Perkins. Your worldview will be in a better, clearer, sharper focus.

Thank you. Keep up the good work!

Leave a Reply


(required)(will not be published)